Why the old workouts stop working in menopause, and what I change
By David Thornhill

Doing the same workouts that used to work, and nothing is changing? It isn't you, and it isn't a lack of effort. Your body has changed, so the plan has to change with it.
I hear this a lot in the gym. Women in their forties and fifties are still running, still going to classes, still eating carefully. The results that used to come have simply stopped. Here's why that happens, and the first things I change.
If you want the bigger picture on muscle and bone, I've written about that in Strength training through menopause. This one is about the routine you already have.
What the scale doesn't show you
One of the best long-term looks we have at this comes from SWAN, a large US study that has followed women through midlife for many years. It scanned their bodies, not just weighed them (Greendale et al., JCI Insight, 2019).
Their weight crept up slowly and steadily, with no sudden jump at menopause. But underneath, the rate of fat gain doubled as the transition began, and lean mass, which is mostly muscle, started to go down.
Those changes began a couple of years before the last period and carried on until about two years after it. So the scale can say almost the same thing while the body underneath it is changing.
That's why so many women feel softer even when the number hasn't moved much. It also tells us what to aim for. The job now is to hold on to muscle, not just to burn calories.
Why doing more stops working
When results stall, most of us do more of what we know: more cardio, more classes, less food. It makes sense, because it worked at 30. Now it often backfires.
Cardio is great for your heart and your head, and we keep it. But on its own it doesn't give your muscle a reason to stay. Cutting food hard on top of it leaves your body even less to build with.
Then there's sleep. The NHS lists trouble falling or staying asleep, night sweats, and muscle and joint aches among the common symptoms of menopause (NHS, menopause symptoms).
Hard sessions every day on broken sleep leave you tired, sore and more likely to give up. So it usually isn't about trying harder. It's about less of the wearing-out work and more of the building work.
What I change in the plan
| What you used to do | What I change | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Mostly cardio and classes | Two or three strength sessions a week first, cardio around them | Muscle needs a reason to stay, and lifting gives it one |
| The same weights for months | A little more weight, or one more rep, when a set feels easy | Your body only adapts to what challenges it |
| Eating as little as possible | Protein at every meal, no crash diet | Muscle needs building material, especially while you lose fat |
| Training hard every day | A hard day, then an easier one | You get stronger while you recover, not while you train |
| Pushing through after a bad night | A lighter session or a walk instead | A tired body lifts badly and gets hurt more easily |
| Judging it all by the scale | Your waist, how clothes fit, what you can lift | The scale misses the change that matters most right now |
On food, keep it simple. Eggs on whole wheat toast, chicken with rice and vegetables, yoghurt with oats. A proper portion of protein at each meal does more for you than skipping another meal.
The NHS also suggests calcium-rich food like milk and yoghurt for your bones, and regular exercise with weight-bearing and resistance work, like using weights, to help protect them (NHS, things you can do). That's the base every one of our programs is built on.
Rest gets the respect it deserves too. A regular bedtime and a day between hard sessions are part of the program, not time off from it.
If your symptoms are hard to live with, speak to your doctor about your options. Training works alongside medical advice, never instead of it.
Where we start
We're all getting older, and that's fine. The point of training now isn't to get your old body back. It's to build the body to do the things you want to do, for many years to come.
If you'd like a plan built for this stage, that's what Boost Go does: my personal training app, with strength sessions at home or in the gym, a short video for every exercise, and a meal plan built around food you already eat.
Try it free for 7 days. Cancel any time. And if you have questions first, message me on WhatsApp on 079 162 9028.
David Thornhill, Boost Fitness, Woodstock, Cape Town
Ready for a plan built around you?
Start my 7 day free trialOn Boost Go. 7 days free, cancel any time.
David Thornhill, Boost Fitness Instagram @david.boostfitness